I subscribe to EGM. They're not bad, which isn't to say I always agree with them. They can get kind of obsessed.

I used to read a bunch of online sites, gamespot and ign.com most notably. I haven't regularly read any online sites in a long time, but my sense is that gamespot is more reliable. ign.com definitely suffers from that Harry Knowles thing, and it seems like the writers have gotten younger every time I go there.