prog: (Default)
prog ([personal profile] prog) wrote2007-07-19 11:40 pm

I'd say "Iorek can beat up Buckbeak" but it'd look like I was missing the point

I fear that my awesome kidlit-expert buddies' drunken snarling about Harry Potter is probably the only backlash I'm gonna see about all of this strangeness, I say, as I gesture around myself. (Other than griefers, but let us not count them.)

I shall read and expect to enjoy the book when the borrowing chain gets 'round to me, and am not totally free of my own little bit of plot speculation. But my goodness, this is the most tension I've ever seen gripping people in my peer group outside of a national election. I think maybe the last time I saw anything like this was around the last episode of M*A*S*H but I was too young to appreciate it at the time. And what this has that that didn't is a sense of real desperation, with many of my friends already half-panicked to get the book, race home, and read it as fast as possible before the forces of evil can spoil it for them. It is somewhat unsettling to see.

Mm. Also, it is kind of fun, isn't it.

[identity profile] hrafn.livejournal.com 2007-07-20 06:13 pm (UTC)(link)
I did my anti-Potter ranting a while back, and no longer feel a need to do more. But I pretty much totally agree with the drunken snarling, all the same, and may, eventually, some year, read more than just the 1st (really not very good) book. I don't really get the enthusiasm.