I don't agree that completed works only stand alone in textual societies. Once you've gone and seen a performance of a story, that performance stands alone. As to your first point, it is likely that an author will be better able to argue from the text, as a result of knowing it better. And if they have written based on their extra knowledge that should be easy to do. And I think your example of Star Wars is a good one. Unauthorized sequels and revisions can be better than the official ones. I think that is more likely in the case of Lucas than the case of Tolkien, but that doesn't preclude the possibility of someone retelling The Hobbit in an interesting way. You may enjoy this humorous look at this exact issue from before the release of HP book 7: Part 1, Part 2
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2007-10-22 11:43 am (UTC)As to your first point, it is likely that an author will be better able to argue from the text, as a result of knowing it better. And if they have written based on their extra knowledge that should be easy to do.
And I think your example of Star Wars is a good one. Unauthorized sequels and revisions can be better than the official ones. I think that is more likely in the case of Lucas than the case of Tolkien, but that doesn't preclude the possibility of someone retelling The Hobbit in an interesting way.
You may enjoy this humorous look at this exact issue from before the release of HP book 7: Part 1, Part 2